Stay On Top of Crap, Got Some Paper?

Search

XML Feeds

User tools

Blog Co-Op
« I'm In but PassionlessClearing Up a Link Diversity MisConception »

Myths about Building an Online Community

01/02/10

Permalink 08:02:09 pm, by Sheryl Email , 711 words, 2624 views   English (US)
Categories: Forums

Myths about Building an Online Community

In the past couple of months I have seen so many people pushing instruction manuals of “Starting an Online Community”. That is not an exact name of a program; it’s just the type of packages they are selling.

Having your own online community is great in many ways.
You can control the topic,
Promote yourself,
Build links……

Yes, you can do all that and more. Those are the type of advantages these ‘community guru’s’ are telling you in all their sales letters.

They know that you will have $ in your eyes, you’ll have visions of heaps of traffic, you may even dream of being on the cover of the Rolling Stone after reading all their hyped up sales letters.

Slow down cowboy…they seem to also be throwing in a few things that are not really the truth for all people.

The biggest bitch I have with these sales letters is they say… You do not have to build content; your members will build it for you. I call Bullshit!

Unless you are someone with a big name and LOTS of good friends…plan on building all of your own content for along time.

On the other hand, if you don’t mind copy and paste ads…then yes, you can get lots of post in your community. You will have enough shit links to build a mountain.

You will also find that many people that want to look as if they are smart will copy other people’s articles and claim them as their own. Now, you have to deal with the pissed off owner of the content.

Another thing the sales letters do not tell you is how much time a community takes to moderate.

Yes, you may have hour’s worth of deleting users and their post.

You will have people that just post where ever they find, no matter if it fits the topic or not.

You will also have to deal with complaints about ads being sent through the personal message system.

I bet you get the idea of what I am saying here.

The only way to stop some of this crap spam is to have a paid or private community.

There are ups and downs to these options.

Both of these options are going to cut way down on your membership. Yet, they will also cut way down on spam.

If you have a paid membership you have the option of letting people in for free or a discount IF you feel they will be a benefit.

You can also make a little money to cover hosting….

There are 2 ways to handle a private community.

1.)Is to have it Invite Only. This is great IF you have a small group that you already know. But, you can pretty much expect the membership to stay the same. Most people will NOT request an invite (or they may not know who to ask).

2.) You can have a ‘hidden’ community. This means that only members can see it. I find these totally USELESS! Most people will never know it even exists. Most owners of these even have them ‘No Index’ so even if you write the best freakin post ever…no one will see it except existing members and I would bet a dollar that one of them will steal it and post it as their own other places.

Now, I do not want to discourage people from building communities, I just thought I would let you in on a few things these ‘gurus’ might not be telling the whole truth about.

I have been an Admin, moderator, and member of forums and communities for years and know that it is not as easy as some would think.

We have The Internet Marketers Guild that is a paid forum. I have built the majority of the content myself. That is fine, I see the incoming SE traffic, I know that people are finding info they want. It’s like an Info Library. If we have a post on the board and I see someone asking for that info...I can just send them a link.

Sheryl Loch

Ps. I have NOT bought any of the Community Building Ebooks or Packages that I am getting spammed with. I am going only on the sales letters they send.

5 comments

Comment from: Sire [Visitor]
SireSheryl, I've been a member of some of those online communities and a lot of them no longer exist. I bet their demise came about because the owner just got sick of the spam and bitching that was happening.

I think the idea you have with The Internet Marketers Guild is a great one. As a member I can see it's potential, I just need to get my arse into gear so that I can utilize it. Perhaps this year I will be able to free up some time so as to become more active.

Recently (01/02/10) Sire wrote A Blogger’s Opinion Is Highly Valued. Check it out!

01/02/10 @ 23:40
Comment from: Mitch [Visitor]
MitchNicely written, Sheryl, and very true indeed. Folks make this sound like a panacea, but I know so many people who created these types of things and just didn't have them work out the way they thought they would. That's just life; I'd rather put my content to better uses.

Recently (01/02/10) Mitch wrote Clearing Away Irritations In 2010. Check it out!

01/03/10 @ 00:31
Comment from: Keith [Visitor]
KeithSo true, I say if you want to build a "community" do it on your blog. I wrote a post about how comments build community last week. I know, different type of community, but I think people get confused and should go back o the basics:
Write Good Content
Comment on Blogs
Reply to Comments on Blog
The End

Recently (01/03/10) Keith wrote Follow Up To Pagerank: It Really Doesn’t Matter. Check it out!

01/04/10 @ 03:58
Comment from: Sheryl Loch [Visitor]
Sheryl LochSire,
Most people set up communities to share useful info and like many things...those that don't have respect for the rules ruin it.

The Guild doesn't have a lot of members but, it doesn't have garbage either. We had to pick quality or quantity.

Mitch, I did not buy any of the packages so, I have no clue if in there they tell you what a pain it could be. Guess it is a little late to find out After they take your money.

I do a lot of the Mini post in the blog section of forums so, I can still push my blog post with the surrounding text and anchor text that I want. I also try to find some questions that are easy to answer. Hopefully I have a post or one of my friends do that I can post a link to help the person find their answer.

Keith, You are right that building your community on your blog is a great way to build your site, load up on info, and stay in touch with people.

We built the guild with the plan to use it as a blog article directory as the main part so people could put an article description and perma link. We know it would make articles you want easier to find. So, it isn't the normal forum. We want the Blog Co-Op to help people build their community on their blog.

Recently (01/06/10) Sheryl Loch wrote Another Great Find - Best Internet Marketing Posts. Check it out!


01/07/10 @ 12:52
Comment from: Premier Team International [Visitor]
Premier Team InternationalI joined a forum years ago and it's still running strong because they have at least half a dozen moderators in addition to the admins keeping things in line. They also have a strict rules system that all posters are expected to follow or suffer temporary/permanant account suspension. It works really well.
02/04/10 @ 13:37